 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Understanding Abnormal Behavior
, Eighth Edition
David Sue, Western Washington University Derald Wing Sue, Teacher's College Stanley Sue, University of California, Davis
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Chapter Outline
Chapter 17:
Therapeutic Interventions
-
Biology-based treatment
techniques (p. 559) Biological treatment techniques have been used
to alter patients psychological states since ancient times. In our
time, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) was first
used in the 1930s on the assumption that seizures would eliminate schizophrenic
behavior. ECT has been found to be useful in treating severe depression, but
the reasons for this are unclear. There is considerable controversy over the
use of ECT. Psychosurgery, particularly lesioning
the frontal lobes, was once a common treatment for schizophrenia, but now
it is used only as a last resort. Videolaserscopy now allows surgeons to make
extremely small laser incisions, guided by a video camera.
Since the 1950s, the most common biology-based
treatments are psychopharmacology (drug therapy) approaches. Some researchers
are concerned about gender bias in prescribing medications: although women
make up only slightly more than half of the patients in psychotherapy, they
receive 73 percent of all prescriptions. Antianxiety drugs, including propanediols
(meprobamate compounds) and benzodiazepines (Librium and Valium), reduce tension
by blocking neural transmission, but they can be addictive and produce withdrawal
symptoms. Antipsychotic drugs (the major tranquilizers) are used to treat
schizophrenia and other psychotic conditions. The phenothiazines have been
more effective than placebos in helping psychotic patients improve social
interactions and self-management, and in decreasing agitation and excitement.
Side effects include Parkinson-like symptoms, dry mouth, and tardive dyskinesia.
Antidepressants include tricyclics, MAO inhibitors, and selective seretonin
reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs/Prozac) and are used to treat depression. Recently
the Food and Drug Administration issued a Black Box warning
on the use of antidepressants with children and adolescents. Lithium, the
principal antimanic drug, is effective in the treatment of bipolar disorder,
but effective dosage borders on toxicity. Psychopharmacological considerations determine
which drug in which amount should be prescribed for which condition an patient.
Drugs are generally more effective for active symptoms like hallucinations
than passive symptoms like social withdrawal, and they do not help patients
improve their living skills. -
Psychotherapy (p.
564) Psychotherapy is defined as the systematic
application of techniques derived from psychological theory for the purpose
of aiding psychologically troubled people. There are wide differences in strategies,
but most psychotherapies agree that treatment is an opportunity for relearning,
for developing new emotionally important experiences, for establishing therapeutic
relationships, and for achieving hoped-for goals. However, traditional psychotherapy
mirrors mainstream Western culture, making it less- effective for those from
non-Western cultures and for members of ethnic minority groups. Mental health
services need to be adapted for multiethnic populations. Individual psychotherapy
is usually subdivided into insight-oriented and action-oriented approaches.
-
Insight-oriented approaches
to individual psychotherapy (p. 566) Psychoanalysis, devised
by Freud, stresses the resolution of unconscious conflicts through techniques
such as free association and dream
analysis, analysis of resistance, the transference relationship, and interpretation of
events. Post-Freudian psychoanalysis is more flexible than traditional psychoanalysis,
but still holds to the idea of symptom substitution if underlying factors
are not analyzed and altered. Among the criticisms of psychoanalysis are that
clients generally are young, white, and highly educated, so the needs of much
of our population are ignored; operational definitions for basic psychoanalytic
concepts are problematic, making it difficult to confirm aspects of the theory;
and controlled research does not confirm the existence of symptom
substitution.
Humanistic-existential approaches
stress the self and personal responsibility. Rogerss person-centered
therapy emphasizes the relationship between therapist and client over
any techniques. Existential analysis adheres to
no single theory but takes a strongly philosophical approach to find meaning
in life, and Perlss gestalt therapy uses
the persons here-and-now totality of experience to produce change.
Because neither existential nor gestalt therapy has generated research, their
effectiveness is hard to evaluate. -
Action-oriented approaches
to individual psychotherapy: Classical conditioning techniques, operant conditioning
techniques, observational learning techniques, and cognitive-behavioral therapy (p.
569) Classical conditioning principles guide the action-oriented therapies
of systematic desensitization, flooding and implosion, aversive conditioning, and covert sensitization. In systematic desensitization,
relaxation is paired with anxiety-provoking scenes to reduce anxiety. In flooding,
clients confront their fears in real situations, whereas in implosion., the
confrontation occurs in imagination. In aversive conditioning, an undesirable
behavior such as smoking is paired with a noxious stimulus. This can be done
in imagination in a procedure called covert sensitization.
Operant principles are at work in token
economies, where desired behaviors are contingently reinforced with
tokens that can be exchanged for privileges or other reinforces. When less
drastic methods are ineffective, punishment may
be used to suppress self-destructive behaviors, as in autistic or schizophrenic
disorders. Modeling, based on
observational learning theory, is effective in the treatment o phobias, delinquency,
and other behavior problems, particularly when models verbalize how to perform
a task and make a few mistakes in the process. Cognitive-behavioral
therapies focus on clients thoughts as well as on their coping
skills. Elliss rational-emotive psychotherapy challenges the clients
irrational beliefs; Becks therapy is less confrontational, but uses
similar themes to treat depression. Stress inoculation therapy is another
form of cognitive-behavioral treatment for learning how to handle life's stresses.
For certain depressions, cognitive-behavioral therapy may be at least as effective
as drug treatment. -
Health psychology (p.
574) Health psychology integrates biological and behavioral sciences for the
purpose of changing peoples lifestyles to prevent illness or to enhance
the quality of their lives. Biofeedback therapy and
counseling to reduce Type A behavior patterns have been useful in this effort.
Most techniques for changing lifestyles involve establishing priorities, avoiding
stressful situations, taking personal time, setting up an exercise schedule,
proper diet, developing social supports, and learning to relax.
-
Evaluating individual
psychotherapy (p. 575) There are debates over the appropriateness of
insight versus action therapies. In 1952, Eysenck created controversy by claiming
that psychotherapy was ineffective. More recent studies have been methodologically
cleaner, but Persons (1991) points out that therapy outcome studies fail to
match the conditions of actual practice of assessment and psychotherapy. Use
of meta-analysis to identify treatment effect
size shows that those getting therapy show far more improvement than
those untreated. Some types of treatment have been rigorously researched and
have demonstrated effectiveness in benefiting clients with certain disorders.
These treatments have been designated as empirically supported treatments
(ESTs) and include cognitive-behavioral therapy for anxiety and depression,
interpersonal therapy for depression and bulimia, and behavioral therapy for
sexual dysfunction. There is a range of factors including experience, therapeutic.
orientation, and demographic characteristics of the therapist that should
go into choosing a therapist. Another approach called the common factors
approach identifies four common dimensions of curative influence in therapy,
Lamber, 1992.
-
Group, family, and
couples therapy (p. 578) Group therapy has economic and therapeutic
advantages over individual psychotherapy. There are many different forms and
structures of group therapy. The purposes and techniques of groups differ
widely, but some common features are the experience of feedback on real-life
social interactions, the opportunity for modeling, and the reduction of isolation
through social support. There are advantages and disadvantages to group treatment.
Measuring outcome for group therapy is more difficult than for individual
treatment.
Family therapy is
a kind of group therapy seeking to modify family relationships to foster greater
harmony. It is based on the assumption that the problems of the identified
patient are symptoms of family distress. Two kinds of family therapy
are the communications approach and the systems
approach. Marital therapy also
focuses on communications and system roles; it is not designed to save marriages,
but to clarify understanding and options. Research on the effectiveness of
family and marital therapy have generally not used rigorous designs, so strong
conclusions are premature. Couples therapy also focuses on communications
and system roles; it is not designed to save relationships, but to clarify
expectations, needs, and communication. Research on the effectiveness of family
and couples therapy have generally not used rigorous designs, so strong conclusions
are premature. -
Systematic integration
and eclecticism (p. 582) Most practicing clinicians see themselves
as eclectics using divers approaches and techniques. An early technical
eclecticism has been refined into a model called multimodal behavior
therapy, which incorporates many cognitive and affective concepts into a behavioral
basis. Practitioners now prefer the term integrative to eclectic.
-
Culturally diverse
populations and psychotherapy (p. 582). Western psychology and mental
health concepts make an assumption that they are universal and that healthy
clients are individualistic and independent and have control over their lives
and the universe, and that self-awareness and personal growth are primary
goals of the therapeutic process. However, many racial/minority groups value
interdependence and collectivism, the group rather than the individual, and
being in harmony with the universe instead of mastering it. Guidelines are
suggested for working with particular groups, but they should not be adhered
to rigidly.
With African Americans it is appropriate to
bring up the issue of racial differences between the client and the white
therapist; to try to understand the African American clients worldview;
rather than pathologizing or prejudging the clients suspiciousness
or reluctance to self-disclose, see it as a survival mechanism and assess
the clients positive assets. Problem-solving approaches are useful
for external problems. With Asian Americans and Pacific Islanders,
therapists should be aware of the potential social stigma of seeing a therapist;
understand that these clients are likely to express psychological conflicts
via somatic complaints and/or other socially acceptable issues; and reluctance
to self-disclose and express feelings may be due to cultural factors, not
psychopathology. The therapist should explain the purpose, expectations, and
process of therapy, and use an action-oriented, problem-solving approach. With Latino or Hispanic American clients, it
helps to engage the client in a warm, respectful manner while maintaining
a formal persona; be sensitive to linguistic misunderstandings (possibly use
a translator); discuss therapy goals with the client; guard against misinterpretations,
particularly of differences in body language; and consider the clients
positive assets and resources, including the nuclear and extended family. With Native Americans, patience is important;
basic needs should be addressed first; understand the importance of the clients
communal environment; be sensitive to differences in communication styles,
especially body language; an consider consulting with indigenous healers. -
Community psychology (p.
587) Community psychology takes into account the
impact of environmental factors on mental health and encourages the use of
community resources to eliminate the conditions that cause psychological problems.
It seeks to promote well-being and prevent psychopathology.
Reform in the delivery of mental health services
is underway in the form of managed health care. Care is shifting to health
maintenance organizations (HMOs), care is increasingly short-term, providers
are more often those with masters degrees, and quality assurance is
emphasized. Unfortunately, the downside may be reduced quality or extent of
services, little effort on persistent problems, and difficulty obtaining long-term
care. Other changes may allow psychologists with appropriate
training to prescribe medications and provide treatment by following treatment
manuals. Preventing psychopathology is a key feature
of community psychology. There are three types. Primary
prevention seeks to lower the incidence of new cases. Examples include
Project Head Start, Munoz and colleagues attempts to prevent depression
community-wide, and early intervention to prevent juvenile delinquency. Secondary prevention attempts to shorten the duration
of disorders by detecting them early and providing effective treatment. There
are problems in providing both primary and secondary prevention. Tertiary
prevention aims to help the readjustment of individuals who have received
hospital treatment.
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
|
|
|