 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Understanding Abnormal Behavior
, Eighth Edition
David Sue, Western Washington University Derald Wing Sue, Teacher's College Stanley Sue, University of California, Davis
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Chapter Outline
Chapter 13:
Schizophrenia: Diagnosis and Etiology
-
Schizophrenia: Diagnosis
and symptoms (p. 419) Schizophrenia is a group of disorders characterized
by cognitive distortions, personality disintegration, affective disturbances,
and social withdrawal. It receives a great deal of attention because it is
so disabling, the prevalence rate is 1 percent (and therefore millions of
people are affected), and its symptoms and causes are diverse. Age of onset
is earlier for males than for females. The lifetime prevalence for schizophrenia
is higher among African Americans and lower among Hispanic Americans than
among the general population.
-
History of the diagnostic
category and DSM-IV-TR (p. 420) Emil Kraepelin first named the disorder dementia praecox (meaning early insanity),
defining it as an early occurring, incurable organic disorder involving progressive
mental deterioration. Eugen Bleuler objected to this, arguing that the disorder
did not necessarily occur early in life. Bleuler proposed that four As
defined the disorder: autism (self-focus), associations (unconnected ideas),
affect (inappropriate emotions), and ambivalence (uncertainty over actions).
He also suggested that schizophrenia was caused by a combination of genetic
and environmental factors with different possibilities for recovery of functioning.
In early editions of the diagnostic manual, schizophrenia was broadly defined,
using Bleulers four As. With the DSM-III, DSM-III-R, and DSM-IV,
the definition became quite restrictive. The current category in DSM-IV-TR
states that a diagnosis of schizophrenia should be given only if delusions,
auditory hallucinations, or marked disturbances in thinking, affect, or speech
have impaired functioning for at least six months at some point in the person's
life and for at least one month currently. Organic causes and affective disorders
must be ruled out.
-
The symptoms of schizophrenia (p.
421) There appear to be three types of symptoms in schizophrenia: psychoticism
(hallucinations and delusions) and disorganization, which are considered positive
symptoms, and flat affect and other forms of social withdrawal, which are
considered negative symptoms.
Positive symptoms: People with schizophrenia
often report delusions (false beliefs) that can take many forms, such as delusions
of grandeur (believing one is a famous person), thought broadcasting (others
can hear the schizophrenics thoughts), or delusions of persecution.
Capgrass syndrome, a rare delusion, is the belief in the existence
of an identical double who may coexist with or replace the schizophrenic or
significant others. Unlike other people, individuals with schizophrenia reach
delusional conclusions on the basis of little information; they can, however,
be trained to challenge their delusions. Hallucinations are sensory perceptions
not attributable to environmental stimuli. Hallucinations are not pathognomonic
(distinctive) to schizophrenia. Auditory hallucinations are most common. Some
believe that auditory hallucinations may stem from subvocal speech, and are
phenomena people with schizophrenia can cope with in a variety of ways. During
times when symptoms are prominent, hallucinations and delusions are so strong
that they are treated as real; in other situations, people with schizophrenia
can ward them off. Schizophrenic individuals have difficulty concentrating
and communicating. One symptom is called loosening of associations, or cognitive
slippage. Thoughts shift from topic to topic, and communication can be vague
or overly concrete. People with schizophrenia also show odd movements or postures;
maintaining an unusual body position is characteristic of catatonic schizophrenia. Negative symptoms are associated with poor prognosis
and may be associated with structural abnormalities in the brain. Some symptoms
are part of the disorder itself (primary symptoms), while others are the result
of medication or hospitalization (secondary symptoms). Examples of negative
symptoms are anhedonia (an inability to feel pleasure) and lack of insight.
Suicide risk factors include severe depression, young age, and traumatic experience.
Cultural factors affect how symptoms are expressed and also affect rate of
diagnosis as well as errors or bias in diagnosis. -
Types of schizophrenia (p.
429) Paranoid schizophrenia is the most common
form of schizophrenia and is characterized by delusions or hallucinations,
usually involving persecution or grandiosity. It is possible to differentiate
this disorder from delusional disorder because
delusional disorder involves less bizarre beliefs and is free from other dysfunctional
behaviors. Disorganized schizophrenia features
severe regression to a childish state without delusions. Behavior and speech
tend to be bizarre. Catatonic schizophrenia is
divided into an excited form marked by hyperactivity and a withdrawn form
in which immobility and waxy flexibility are seen. Often patients swing from
one state to the other. Undifferentiated schizophrenia is
a form marked by a mix of symptoms; residual schizophrenics are
those people whose symptoms are in remission.
-
Psychotic disorders
once considered schizophrenia, and other psychotic disorders (p. 431)
In DSM-IV-TR, the term schizophrenia is reserved
for psychotic episodes lasting six months or more. Brief
psychotic disorder is diagnosed when symptoms have lasted less than
one month; the disorder in which symptoms last between one and six months
is called schizophreniform disorder. DSM-IV-TR
recommends these disorders be provisional. About two-thirds
of those diagnosed with schizophreniform disorder will later be diagnosed
with schizophrenia or schizoaffective disorder.
Other psychotic disorders include shared psychotic disorder,
in which a person who has a close relationship with a delusional person accepts
those beliefs, and schizoaffective disorder, a combination of mood disorder
and psychotic symptoms that last at least two weeks.
-
The course of schizophrenia (p.
433) Most people with schizophrenia show poor premorbid personality before
the onset of the disorder. The typical course of schizophrenia consists of
three phases. The prodromal phase includes social
withdrawal and peculiar speech or actions. In the active
phase, symptoms are in full evidence, and by the residual
phase, symptoms are no longer prominent. International studies show
that return to work and reduction in symptoms is more common in developing
countries than in the United States, the former Soviet Union, or Western Europe.
This may be due to misdiagnosis rather than true recovery.
It is unclear what the long-term outcome of
schizophrenia tends to be. Because diagnosis requires that symptoms be present
for at least six months, it makes sense that someone with a diagnosis of schizophrenia
has a more severe condition than someone who recovered sooner; thus schizophrenia
is defined as a chronic condition. However, in one long-term study, 26 percent
of the patients had complete remission, and about 50 percent had partial remission
of symptoms. Differences in outcome may be due to criteria used to define
schizophrenia. Most individuals with schizophrenia recover enough to lead
relatively productive lives. -
Etiology of schizophrenia (p.
434) The causes of schizophrenia may involve genetic, physiological, psychological,
and environmental factors. Therapies include neuroleptics (antipsychotic medication)
and psychotherapy, but relapse rates remain too high. Researchers disagree
on the impact of social and genetic factors in the cause and development of
this disorder.
-
Heredity and schizophrenia (p.
435) The highest probability of selecting a schizophrenic from the general
population would be reached by finding an individual with an identical twin
who has the disorder. Problems in interpreting genetic studies and studies
involving blood relatives. Genetic studies are limited by the variety of subtypes
of the disorder, as well as by sampling and definitional problems.
We might assume that the closer the blood relationship
between a person and a diagnosed schizophrenic, the higher the probability
of the disorder in that person. However, relatedness and risk are not always
linked because of problems in defining schizophrenia, in
reliably diagnosing individuals, and in biased selection and analysis. Furthermore,
such studies confound genetics and environment. The child of a person with
schizophrenia has a 12- to 13-percent chance of developing; the risk in the
general population is about 1 percent. Twin studies and adoption studies. Since
their genes are identical, we would assume that there would be stronger concordance
rates among MZ twins than among DZ twins (who share about 50 percent of their
genes) if schizophrenia is genetically transmitted. Concordance
rates are usually two to four times higher in MZ twins than in DZ twins,
but method problems, including definitions along the schizophrenia spectrum,
account for a wide range in these findings. Clearly, there is a genetic influence
in this disorder. Adoption studies screen out the effects of family
environment. Heston (1966) found that five or forty-seven at-risk children
(adoptees having schizophrenic birth mothers) later became schizophrenics
themselves, but none of the control adoptees did. However, many at-risk children
also became creative, successful adults. Other adoption studies also support
the idea that heredity plays a major role in the transmission of schizophrenia.
Kety et al. (1994) found that, among adoptees who developed schizophrenia,
the disorder tended to exist in the relatives of the biological parents but
not those of the adoptive parents. Studies of high-risk populations. High-risk
studies are developmental comparisons between children with schizophrenic
parents and those with nonschizophrenic parents. Results of Mednick et al.s
research show that children who became sick had mothers with more severe schizophrenic
symptoms, who had experienced complications giving birth. They were also more
disruptive as children and had a slower autonomic recovery rate. Israeli prospective studies indicate that schizophrenia has only
developed among high-risk children. Social withdrawal was the characteristic
most related to risk of developing the disorder. However, none of the high-risk
children receiving adequate parenting developed schizophrenia or a schizophrenia-like
disorder. The most striking finding is the relative absence of severe
psychopathology in most of the subjects. Although high-risk
population studies are a promising line of research, they have no control
groups with other forms of psychopathology, generalizations may be difficult,
and relevant variables and appropriate definitions of disorder may be missing. -
Physiological factors
in schizophrenia (p. 441) After previous dead ends, the idea that a
chemical imbalance exists in schizophrenics shows promise. The effects of
phenothiazine drugs, L-dopa, and amphetamines support the dopamine hypothesis,
which suggests that dopamine activity in certain areas of the brain is excessive
in people with schizophrenia. However, some patients do not respond to phenothiazines
or L-dopa in ways predicted by this biochemical theory. This could be due
to there being varieties of schizophrenia. Other drugs, such as Clozapine,
implicate the neurotransmitter serotonin.
Research supports the view that, especially
in schizophrenics who show such negative symptoms as flat affect, there are
neurological abnormalities, including cerebral atrophy and low cerebral glucose
metabolism in the frontal lobes. These differences are seen in identical twins
who are discordant for the disorder. People with schizophrenia show poorer
sustained attention and eye movement coordination than nonschizophrenics,
differences that are considered cognitive markers. However, even stable neurological
abnormalities are not specific to schizophrenia and may be seen in normal
controls, and some treatment effects run counter to prediction. Heinrichs
points out many contradictions in the disorder and suggests that schizophrenia
is a heterogeneous illness that paradoxically resists subdivision. -
Environmental factors
in schizophrenia (p. 445) Lacking any definitive genetic or biological
basis for schizophrenia, researchers also look at environmental causes, including
infections or disruptions of normal brain development during fetal and perinatal
periods. Environmental factors act as stressors and thereby help produce psychopathology.
Stress may induce hallucinations and trigger relapse.
Family influences are an important source of
stress. Environmental factors act as stressors and thereby help produce psychopathology.
Stress may induce hallucinations and trigger relapse. The family is an important
source of stress. Psychodynamic theory focused on the personality of the schizophrenic mother, whereas family systems theory stresses
the double-bind theory of communication patterns.
Research on family influence has been hampered both by observations after
the child has been diagnosed and by the lack of control groups. Expressed emotion (EE)highly critical,
hostile, and overinvolved parentingis related to increased relapse
among schizophrenics, especially those who have stopped taking medication.
However, as with other environmental factors, it is not clear whether these
problems are the effect of schizophrenia or its cause; neither does EE appear
to be pathognomonic for the disorder. Schizophrenia is more common in the lower social
classes than in the upper ones. Theories attribute this to the stress of
poverty (breeder hypothesis) or downward
drift theory (the loss in income occurring because the disorder makes
earning a good living difficult). Research evidence can support both positions.
Symptoms of schizophrenia in various countries studied appear to reflect
cultural beliefs specific to the culture. -
The treatment of schizophrenia (p.
450)Antipsychotic medication (neuroleptics)is the
principal means of treating schizophrenia today. A new drug, Clozapine, may
be effective in cases not previously helped by neuroleptics. Although effective
in many cases, medications can produce neurological conditions, including tardive dyskinesia, a disorder of involuntary movements
for which there is no cure. Other side effects have led to legal action to
provide patients with the right to refuse such medical treatment. Clinicians
often misinterpret or ignore the symptoms of drug side effects. The need
for maintenance dosages for schizophrenics is currently in question.
Psychosocial therapy is now often paired with
drug treatment. Patients reported deriving most help from practical advice
therapists give; they value the therapists friendship. In inpatient
settings, milieu therapy and social learning treatment
have been shown to be more effective than the traditional treatment. Milieu
therapy allows patients to take more responsibility for decision-making. Cognitive-behavioral
approaches have been useful in reducing delusions and hallucinations, and
improving social skills. Intervention to reduce expressed emotion in
families has also proven useful in reducing relapse rates. Families are given
information about the disorder and taught ways to alter communication patterns.
Schizophrenic patients can also be taught to respond to their parents
emotions more appropriately. Combining various treatments gives hope for
even more successful therapy for schizophrenia in the future.
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
|
|
|