 |
 |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Understanding Abnormal Behavior
, Eighth Edition
David Sue, Western Washington University Derald Wing Sue, Teacher's College Stanley Sue, University of California, Davis
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
Chapter Outline
Chapter 6:
Dissociative Disorders and Somatoform Disorders
-
Dissociative and somatoform
disorders (p. 171) The dissociative disorders show altered
or disrupted identity, memory, or consciousness; the somatoform
disorders involve physical symptoms that have no physiological basis.
Both disorders occur because of some psychological need and both rely on self-reports,
and so are subject to faking. There are four dissociative disorders: dissociative
amnesia, dissociative fugue, dissociative identity disorder (formerly called
multiple-personality disorder), and depersonalization disorder. Except for
depersonalization, dissociative disorders are rare, although there has been
a dramatic increase in reports of dissociative identity disorder.
-
Dissociative amnesia (p.
172) Dissociative amnesia is the partial or total
loss of important personal information, often occurring in response to a stressful
event. There are five types. Localized amnesia is
characterized by total memory loss for a particular, short time period, and
is the most common form. In selective amnesia,
the memory loss is for details about an incident. Total loss of memory for
ones past life is the criterion for generalized
amnesia, systematized amnesia involves the
loss of memory for only selected types of information, and total loss of memory
from one point in time to another occurs in continuous
amnesia. Repression of a traumatic event seems to be the main reason
for psychogenic amnesia; a similar process occurs
in posthypnotic amnesia. There is great controversy about the validity of
uncovered, repressed memories for child abuse.
-
Dissociative fugue
and depersonalization disorder (p. 174) In dissociative
fugue, memory loss is accompanied by flight to another area and establishment
of a new identity. Recovery from this and from psychogenic amnesia is usually
abrupt and complete.
Depersonalization disorder
is characterized by feelings of unreality or distorted perceptions
of the body or environment. It is more common than the other dissociative
disorders, tends to be chronic, is often accompanied by mood or anxiety disorders,
and can be precipitated by stress. -
Dissociative identity
disorder (multiple-personality disorder) (p. 177) In dissociative
identity disorder, two or more (often many more) distinct personalities
exist in one individual. Not all personalities are aware of one another. However,
even objective testing with physiological measurements produces conflicting
findings about the existence of distinct personalities. Although this condition
was once thought to be rare, there has been a dramatic increase in reported
cases, perhaps because of the influence of therapists while clients are under
hypnosis. People with dissociative identity disorder often report a history
of childhood abuse. Diagnosis in childhood is possible, but misdiagnosis is
common, both by seeing the disorder in people who have other problems and
by failing to see multiple personality in people diagnosed with other disorders.
Diagnosis is much more common in the United States and Canada than in other
parts of the world.
-
Etiology and treatment
of dissociative disorders (p. 181) The causes of dissociative disorders
are subject to a good deal of conjecture because faking is always a possibility.
The psychodynamic perspective sees repression of, unpleasant emotions as the
cause of dissociative disorders. Splits in consciousness protect the individual
from anxiety and pain. Behavioral theorists suggest that avoidance of stress
is the main causative factor. One of the current approaches, the sociocognitive
model, conceptualizes DID as a syndrome with rule-governed and goal-directed
experiences, and displays of multiple role enactments created, legitimized,
and maintained by social reinforcement. The disorder may also be the unintended
effect of treatment, an iatrogenic condition. The
expectations of therapists 'and their use of hypnosis, which increases suggestibility,
may create memories of abuse and personalities.
Recovery from dissociative amnesia, dissociative
fugue, and depersonalization disorder often occurs spontaneously; therefore,
treatment often aims at reducing the depression or anxiety these conditions
produce. Dissociative identity disorder is usually treated with psychotherapy
and hypnosis, but not with notable success. Behavior therapists use contingent
reinforcement for the healthy personality and extinction for
the others. -
Somatoform disorders (p.
186) The principal symptoms of somatoform disorders are
complaints of physical symptoms that have no apparent physiological cause.
Faking is possible, but when symptoms such as fever are consciously induced,
they are considered factitious disorders rather
than malingering, which involves voluntary faking
for monetary or other rewards. Somatic complaints are far more common in non-Western
cultures where a somatopsychic view (physical problems produce emotional symptoms)
is more prevalent than the Western psychosomatic view (internal conflicts
are expressed as physical symptoms).
-
Somatization disorder
and conversion disorder (p. 188) In somatization
disorder, individuals have physical complaints in four or more different
sites in the body, symptoms for which there are no physiological explanations.
Complaints include gastrointestinal, sexual, and pseudoneurological symptoms.
If the individual does not fully meet the criteria but has at least one physical
complaint for six months, the diagnosis would be undifferentiated somatoform
disorder. Patients shop around for doctors and often have unneeded surgery.
Somatization disorder, formerly called hysteria, is rarely diagnosed in men
although over one third of males referred for unexplained somatic complaints
meet the criteria for the disorder. A cross-cultural study found it to be
relatively rare. Interestingly, somatoform disorders are not included in China's
most recently revised counterpart to the DSM; the Chinese have commented that
somatization is a Western construct.
In conversion disorder, there
is a significant physical impairment, such as paralysis in a limb or sensory
problems, without physical basis. When neurological or other processes prove
the symptoms impossible (such as in glove anesthesia), diagnosis is readily
made; otherwise, it is quite hard to differentiate conversion disorder from
actual illnesses or faking. -
Pain disorder, hypochondriasis,
and body dysmorphic disorder (p. 192) Pain that is excessive, lingers
too long, or is unrelated to a physiological cause is characteristic of Pain disorder. As with ordinary pain, there is a complex
interaction among perception, thinking, and behavior
In hypochondriasis, there
is a consistent preoccupation with illness in the face of doctors repeated
assurances of health. Those with hypochondriasis often have a history of illness
and parents who focused on illness. Fear, anxiety, and depression are common
complaints. Body dysmorphic disorder involves
an excessive concern with an imagined or slight physical defect such as facial
features, excessive hair, or the shape of genitals. Individuals with this
disorder frequently check their appearance in the mirror and fear that others
are looking at the defect. They make frequent requests for plastic surgery
regardless of the treatment's outcome. Because the disorder involves obsessive
thinking and delusions, its placement in the diagnostic category of somatoform
disorders has been questioned. It is also not clear where normal concerns
about appearance end and the disorder begins. -
Etiology and treatment
of somatoform disorders (p. 195) A diathesis-stress view
of somatoform disorders suggests that individuals are hypersensitive to bodily
sensations and are predisposed to react strongly to somatic sensations. In
the event of a stressor, they develop intense bodily complaints and symptoms.
Psychoanalysts believe that repression accounts for the process of converting
unconscious conflicts into physical symptoms. There is primary
gain in the reduction of anxiety and secondary
gain in the sympathy the individual receives. Behavioral theorists
contend that a sick role is reinforced by others and helps the
person escape from responsibilities. The sociocultural perspective stresses
that, historically, social norms did not provide women with appropriate channels
for the expression of aggressive or sexual needs. As a result, women developed
hysterical symptoms. The biological perspective notes that individuals with
somatoform disorders are unusually sensitive to bodily sensations and have
higher arousal levels than others.
Psychoanalytic treatment emphasizes the need
to relive unpleasant experiences so that they can be mastered rather than
converted into symptoms. Behavioral therapists advise extinction for complaints
and reinforcement for healthy behavior. Cognitive-behavioral treatments focus
on changing the conscious thoughts and expectations of clients. Family therapists
teach family members to support one another without resorting to physical
symptoms and to anticipate such problems. Biological treatment consists of
antidepressant medication for the somatization disorder; increased physical
activity for conversion disorder; and SSRIs for body dysmorphic disorder.
|  |  |  |  |  |  |  |
|
|
|